Skip to main content

Megha Majumdar

Reading Megha Majumdar's A Guardian And A Thief  for a book club. 

Why am I just noticing Calcutta is now spelled Kolkata? It was changed in 2001! I need like spelling updates on Bluesky, except Bluesky has only really existed for me November 2023. 




My experience reading this book is one of horrified anxiety. What terrible thing is going to happen next? I hope to connect to my hope, that they will surmount these trials, but I'm not so sure. In a way it's perfectly set up to tug at my heartstrings. The father is off working in another land. The mother cares for a little girl and an elderly father in a starving Kolkata, where all ethics is out of the window as people steal food. There's a fragile preciousness as lots of things almost happen and the horrors build. 

I don't like the title, it makes you focus on who the thief is. Beautiful cover art.

The first apocalypse novel I read was Lucifer's Hammer. I remember thinking the genre had potential. I was on my honeymoon, and it all seemed remote. Now I'm older and my world is shrinking and I wonder if these kind of novels prepare you for aging, and I'm having nightmares, and this novel touches me very deeply. 

Everytime the water goes off, or the electricity doesn't work, I ask, is this it? I hear a loud boom in the distance.

She lies to her husband so he won't worry, that is maybe a kindness, but I wouldn't want to be lied to. To lie to someone is to infantilize them. Perhaps it's wise, shielding the truth about which someone can't do anything. I never considered lying can help maintain relationships as The Departed (2006) suggests. 

I think it's cool, when someone does something irritating and then you get their back story, and then you can see where they're coming from. 

When I first started reading the book, I needed to read 7 pages a day to be ready for the book club. Now after 5 days not reading because of the flu, I need to read 30 pages a day to be ready. 


Links:

No Saints or Villains: An Interview with Megha Majumdar (Chicago Review of Books).

Megha Majumdar on the Joy of Asking Questions (Literary Hub).

Labels:

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

The case for Harris

Motley Kamuka Blog endorses Kamala Harris. In general, Trump just wants to lower taxes on the rich, and do nothing, sell whatever influence he can to line his pockets. Apparently the emoluments clause in the constitution has no teeth. Harris has a set of ideas about policy that are fairly middle of the road. In most countries she's would be seen as a centrist. Spin about her radical agendas are exaggerated.  I'm not sure how he got past " grab them by the pussy ", but he did and here we are. Women: Obviously the idea of giving women pregnancy tests at the borders of the state, and then if they come back and don't have a baby, they go to jail, isn't really what most women want. Pick Harris.  I understand if you think abortion is murder, maybe you've been told that by the Catholic church, which has the same ideal of Buddhism that you don't kill--so follow your religion for yourself. Not everyone is Christian or Buddhist or even has a religion. Women are ...
Post a Comment
Read more

AOC

Dark Brandon meet Dark Alex. I see her advising the republicans to stick to their guns and never compromise. They don’t want to do anything, only obstruct. So they don’t actually need to be unified. Chaos isn’t organized. This is fine. Read all about it from Heather Cox Richardson , a historian who covers current events. "As their policies threatened to lose voters by concentrating wealth upward and hollowing out the middle class, Republicans increasingly warned that minority voters wanted socialism and were destroying the nation to get it. Trump rode that narrative to power, and now tearing down the current government is the idea that drives the Republican base." While we're at it, here's another funny photo from the Onion: And then: I listened to the Times podcast about George Santos . He basically lied about, I don't know, 80% of his resume, and has a mysterious $700k in his "corporation" which has no clients. So he's a Russian or Chinese plant, o...
Post a Comment
Read more

Manet and Degas

  Brilliant video explaining the exhibit. Go to the Met and see the exhibit! It's really quite special.  In the last gallery the painting this sketch is based off of, of the execution of a Mexican president. The painting has been cut into sections, and the surviving Degas has reassembled them. NY Times review
Post a Comment
Read more