Skip to main content

Megha Majumdar

Reading Megha Majumdar's A Guardian And A Thief  for a book club. 

Why am I just noticing Calcutta is now spelled Kolkata? It was changed in 2001! I need like spelling updates on Bluesky, except Bluesky has only really existed for me November 2023. 




My experience reading this book is one of horrified anxiety. What terrible thing is going to happen next? I hope to connect to my hope, that they will surmount these trials, but I'm not so sure. In a way it's perfectly set up to tug at my heartstrings. The father is off working in another land. The mother cares for a little girl and an elderly father in a starving Kolkata, where all ethics is out of the window as people steal food. There's a fragile preciousness as lots of things almost happen and the horrors build. 

I don't like the title, it makes you focus on who the thief is, but that is the point of the book. Beautiful cover art.

The first apocalypse novel I read was Lucifer's Hammer. I remember thinking the genre had potential. I was on my honeymoon, and it all seemed remote. Now I'm older and my world is shrinking and I wonder if these kind of novels prepare you for aging, and I'm having nightmares, and this novel touches me very deeply. 

In my life, everytime the water goes off, or the electricity doesn't work, I ask, is this it? I hear a loud boom in the distance.

She lies to her husband so he won't worry, that is maybe a kindness, but I wouldn't want to be lied to. To lie to someone is to infantilize them. Perhaps it's wise, shielding the truth about which someone can't do anything. I never considered lying can help maintain relationships as The Departed (2006) suggests. 

I think it's cool, when someone does something irritating and then you get their back story, and then you can see where they're coming from. 

When I first started reading the book, I needed to read 7 pages a day to be ready for the book club. Now after 5 days not reading because of the flu, I need to read 30 pages a day to be ready. 

I pick the book up today and I struggle to want to keep seeing problem after problem. Why am I so fragile, why do I struggle to see this as art, instead of rubbing my nose in it? Does this novel toughen me up? I'm not sure what sort of reward I'm looking for.

Mosambi is what they call lemons in India. 

I had a really hard time finishing this novel. I know it's only 205 pages, but I'd read a page, and it was be so bleak and depressing. I finally finished it. Took me 2.5 months to read. Really hard for me to read. 


Links:

No Saints or Villains: An Interview with Megha Majumdar (Chicago Review of Books).

Megha Majumdar on the Joy of Asking Questions (Literary Hub).

I watched Mother (2025) directed by Teona Strugar Mitevska, about the last 7 days before Mother Teresa started her order, with permission. It is set in Kolkata. I think there are some authentic recent scenes of Kolkata. Maybe somewhat staged. I watched the Apu trilogy, and even though it's 1950/60 kolkata, it's a great bunch of movies, I really liked them. 

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

movie versus book

I'm watching the movie a second time, and I'm halfway through the book. Among the movie's differences from the book. Sortilege starts off narrating. The movie doesn't have the school bell for the phone either, just a regular ring. It's really weird the way Doc shouts when he sees the photo of Amethyst as a baby. I guess it's to dramatize the negative impact of being pregnant and using, but the child we see looks pretty healthy. The child doesn't huff out because they're boring like she did in the book.  Superficially The Big Lebowski and Inherent Vice are similar but it's a completely different style of narrative. The Coen brothers are amazing, they have a very witty movie that I have loved for a long time. Pynchon is a whole other realm of fiction, and this conversion is fairly faithful, taking out the best lines and making it more compact. The audio book is 15 hours, the movie is 2 hours. Anyway, I like the different movies for different reasons. T...

Manet and Degas

  Brilliant video explaining the exhibit. Go to the Met and see the exhibit! It's really quite special.  In the last gallery the painting this sketch is based off of, of the execution of a Mexican president. The painting has been cut into sections, and the surviving Degas has reassembled them. NY Times review

Silo

This is a dark show that I'm reluctant to watch. Slow burn with reveals along the way. Lots of padding and important small details you have to pay attention to, which sometimes I don't because I'm looking at my phone. The TV competes with the phone. Either I'm playing chess, or another game, or surfing for news about my favorite soccer team NYCFC. They're supposed to sign some new players and can register them tomorrow, but the team usually doesn't do things in a timely way, they're messy.  The first few episodes of the 10 episode first season are about the sherif and his wife, played by Rashid Jones .  Then there's like a buffer action episode where the generator almost goes kaput. Then it becomes Longmire, a woman sheriff who doesn't know the protocols and rules, and doesn't care, she just wants truth and answers.  Everyone lives in the Silo, it's huge and mysterious and you can't have relics, things from the past, that might clue you i...